The terror attack on the Charlie Hebdo satirical magazine last month gave rise to much debate and reflection that offered a multiplicity of perspectives. Here academic Mahmood Mamdani shares some interesting insights, in an interview with The Hindu.
Back with a Prophet Mohammed cartoon on its cover, Charlie Hebdo, the French satirical magazine, has resolved to take on Islamic fundamentalists, after a terror attack on its office premises in Paris last Wednesday claimed the lives of 10 staff members including that of its editor, Stephane Charbonnier. In an email interview to Vidya Venkat, Professor Mahmood Mamdani, Herbert Lehman Professor of Government and Professor of Anthropology at Columbia University, author of Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror, explained the difference between critiquing a religion and ridiculing it, and why it is one thing to oppose censorship and quite another thing to reprint Charlie Hebdo cartoons in solidarity. Edited excerpts: In the wake of the Charlie Hebdo terror attacks, there is widespread condemnation of Islam itself.
George Packer, in his New Yorker article, for example, had held Islam and its tenets and those believing in them responsible for the attacks. Are we misdiagnosing the problem here?
In my view, George Packer’s is a knee-jerk response. It fails to recognise what is new about the Charlie Hebdo killings. The information we have so far suggests that it was a paramilitary operation. Though carried out by a local unit, decentralised in both planning and execution, the attack was strategised and sanctioned from headquarters.
The killings need to be seen as a strategic and organised military attack. As such, it is different from the kind of grassroots demonstrations we have seen in the past, such as in responses to the Danish Cartoons.
Proponents of the Charlie Hebdo brand of humour and satire see the need to share and endorse the culture of “free speech”. Your view?
I support the right of free speech as part of a right of dissent. But that does not mean that I support every particular exercise of free speech or dissent. It is well known that the history of free speech is contradictory. We recognise it by distinguishing ‘hate speech’ from other forms of free speech. Some states ban ‘hate speech’ legally, other states refrain from a legal ban and leave it to society to discourage it politically and morally.
When asked to comment on the Danish Cartoons on Prophet Mohamed, the German novelist Günter Grass said they reminded him of anti- Semitic cartoons in a German magazine, Der Stürmer. The New York Times piece that carried the interview with Gunter Grass added that the publisher of Der Stürmer was tried at Nuremberg and executed. Among those tried in Arusha following the Rwanda genocide was a radio journalist. Following mass violence in the Rift Valley in Kenya, the ICC issued a list of those charged with crimes against humanity; one of these was a radio journalist. In all three cases, the journalists were accused of spreading hate speech.
My own preference is for the political and the intellectual over the legal. I am against all forms of censorship. While I think you have a right to say what you think, I will not support anything you say or write. I also reserve the right to disagree with you, vehemently if necessary. It is one thing to support the right of Charlie Hebdo journalists to print the cartoons they did, and quite another to reprint them as an expression of support.
Blasphemous cartoons with a sexual theme, as some of Charlie Hebdo’s cartoons were, are not new in Europe. But in places such as Britain such cartoons, for example, that of Siné published by Penguin books, have been removed having internalised legal restraint as civility. Is that kind of compromise of power even possible now with voices in the West strongly condemning the terror attacks and using it to channelise their collective anger against Islamic fundamentalism?
Western societies have worked out internal compromises over time in an endeavour to build durable political societies. The scope and nature of these compromises are politically defined. Their thrust is to call a ceasefire in struggles of great historical significance in the name of civility. In many Western countries, there are laws against blasphemy. But they are restricted to official Christian denominations. For example, Britain has laws criminalising blasphemy, as do several other European countries, but they do not apply to Islam.
Before the Second World War, Jews were the customary target of satirists of a particular type. Voltaire, popularly considered the founding father and grand defender of the freedom to satire, was an ardent anti-Semite, and a number of his satires targeted Jews and Judaism. After the Holocaust, Jews were brought into the Western political fold. It became conventional to speak of a Judeo-Christian heritage in the West, when it had been customary to speak of a longstanding conflict between Judaism and Christianity before. So, today the law in many European countries, including France, criminalises Holocaust denial. But no law criminalises the denial of colonial genocide, including widespread colonial massacres in Algeria, the country of origin of the largest number of French Muslims.
The political and social compact in Europe has been evolving historically. The state stepped in to moderate the conflict between ardent Christians and secular Christians.
Jews were included in this compact after the Holocaust. Muslims have never been part of this compact. The Muslim minority in Europe is the largest in France, around 10 per cent. In the Mediterranean city of Marseille, it is roughly 30 per cent. It represents the weakest and the most disenfranchised section of French society. There are more Muslims in the French police and security services than there are in al-Qaeda or other terrorist cells. But you would not know it. At the same time, the representation of Muslims in the French elite, whether political, economic or cultural, is nominal, the exception being the French football team, once led by the legendary Zinnedine Zidane.
Of course, it is possible to include Muslims in the social and political compact in France. But that will take a major political, intellectual and cultural struggle. Centres of power – and people – in France will have to accept that it is possible to be French and Muslim, that it is OK for a pious Muslim woman to wear a ‘hijab’, as it is for a Catholic nun – so long as this act of piety does not banish either from participation in the public sphere. In other words, we are talking of a political struggle for meaningful citizenship.
You have referred to the case of Siné published by Penguin Books. I wrote about it when discussing the Danish Cartoon controversy. The example goes back to 1967 when Britain’s leading publishing house, Penguin, published an English addition of a book of cartoons by France’s most acclaimed cartoonist, Siné. The Penguin edition of Massacre was introduced by Malcolm Muggeridge, and carried a number of anticlerical and blasphemous cartoons, some of them with a sexual theme. In the wake of complaints by a number of his bookshop friends that the cartoons were likely to offend practicing Christians, Allen Lane took precipitate action: He went to Penguin’s Harmondsworth warehouse with four accomplices, filled a trailer with all the remaining copies of the book, drove away and burnt them. The next day the Penguin trade department reported the book ‘out of print’.
In that same piece, I cited an additional case which is also relevant to this discussion.
This concerns the Amos and Andy show in the U.S. It began as a radio programme in 1928 and graduated to prime time television in 1951 and then a syndicated show in 1953. Every year, the NAACP would protest that the show was a racist caricature of black people, implying that “Negroes are inferior, lazy, dumb and dishonest,” that every character in the all-Black show “is either a clown or a crook.” The CBS turned a deaf ear to this, every year, until the Watts riots in 1965. CBS withdrew the show in the aftermath of the Watts riots. Even then, CBS’ official Amos ‘n Andy website said it hoped that Black people will learn to laugh at themselves: “Perhaps we will collectively learn to lighten up, not get so bent out of shape, and learn to laugh at ourselves a little more.”
That people “need to learn to laugh at themselves” is often a point made by publishers of provocative cartoons. You could place those same words in the mouth of the publishers of the Danish Cartoons or Charlie Hebdo, and it would reflect their views accurately, that the problem with Muslims is that they lack a sense of humor, and that the solution is for Muslims to learn to laugh at themselves. But laughing at oneself is not quite the same as being laughed at, especially as a group. Let me return to the question of what you call the ‘blasphemous cartoons.’ I think they should be called ‘bigoted cartoons.’
The problem with the ongoing discussion of Charlie Hebdo is that it tends to confuse bigotry with blasphemy. I am personally more favourable to blasphemy, but have no time for bigots or bigotry. Blasphemy is part of an important historical practice that involves critiquing a tradition from within. That kind of capacity for self-critique, for laughing at oneself, is absolutely necessary for the ongoing reform of traditions and cultures in the face of changing realities, changing mores and changing intellectual constructs. In Islam, the right to critique tradition from within is known as Ijtihad. It has a long and honourable history.
It is generally assumed that with the emergence of modernity, religion as a social institution loses its hold over people’s lives and over society in general. But given the emergence of fundamentalist forces, in renewed forms like IS, do we have to rethink the role of religion in shaping social phenomena?
You will excuse me if I disagree with the premise of your question. Durkheim defined religion as a mode of thought and practice that defines objects and actions as either sacred or profane. In this sense, the secular world can be equally religious: the state takes the place of an official religion, the flag or the national anthem becomes sacred objects, and so on.
Second, the notion that modernity will civilise the world by doing away with barbarism and superstition (‘pre-modernity) has turned out to be a superstition itself. The tendency of modernity has been to harness pre-modern practices and institutions to modern political projects, thereby politicising (and thus ‘modernising’) them. Both religion and tradition (in a secular sense) have become politicised. Just think of how the CIA militarised madressas in Pakistan to wage the Afghan jihad during the Soviet occupation.
We are going through a resurgence of politicised religion and politicised tradition.
Think of the parties in Europe that now organise in defence of ‘Europe’ and against immigrants (really Muslims). Think of born-again Christianity and its remarkable political influence in the U.S. Think of political Zionism, both in Israel and the U.S.
Think of the BJP and the myriad Sangh Sabha organisations in India who want a Hindu state as the surest guarantee for the defence of Hindu tradition. And think of radical Islamist groups that want an ‘Islamic state’ as a guarantee of a return to Islam.
My point is that we are seeing a resurgence of movements around the world that speak the language of nativism, tradition and religion. Not all of them are reactionary.
We should be careful not to judge the contents largely by the packaging. In my view, the debate inside tradition and religion is as important the debate between secular and religious traditions.
Soon after 9/11 happened, you wrote: “Ascribing the violence of one’s adversaries to their culture is self-serving: it goes a long way toward absolving oneself of any responsibility.” Do you see European policies on immigration and assimilation of minorities at home (or the failure to do that very well) as contributing to terrorism?
The French like to think of themselves as the custodians of the tradition of liberty, equality and fraternity. That is true but it is not the whole truth. The French also need to think of the dark side of their tradition: the colonial tradition, both in Indo-China and Africa. The French need to recognise that the Algerians, the North Africans and the West Africans from the former colonies are in France as immigrants, because the French were in their countries in the first place. These immigrants have run away from the consequences of colonialism. If the solution – France – has turned sour, where do these immigrants run to now? To an imaginary Islamic state? If a second or third generation North African is still considered an immigrant in France, should that not provide us a clue as to the nature of the problem? Where lies the problem, the promise of the Islamist state, or the reality of immigrant lives in contemporary France, or both?
Do you see an intensification of the post-9/11 type of Islamophobia emerging in these countries now that the murders have provided further justification?
9/11 was centrally planned, organised and executed. In contrast, Charlie Hebdo was locally planned and executed, even if the strategy and the sanction was central. This is one difference we need to appreciate. The response to the Danish Cartoons was in the main a street-level response of ordinary Muslims who saw themselves as being framed and set up by forces of bigotry.
The Charlie Hebdo killings were done by a military cell, coordinated and guided from a centre. This was a strategic strike, not a spontaneous demonstration. This is a second difference we need to appreciate. The tragedy is that neither the left nor the centre seem to take these differences as the starting point for their response. So long as a knee-jerk response is the order of the day, I am afraid we will concede both intellectual and political leadership to the right. If this trend continues, Islamophobia is likely to grow from an intellectual tendency to a hate movement in France and other sections of Europe.
All the religions that I am familiar with teach love and compassion and forgiveness at their core. Some of their followers twist and subvert this in grotesque ways but that does not make the religion bad, it makes them bad. People put layers of rules onto the central teachings which are in some cases beneficial and in others harmful.
Generally a good account.Prediction is wrong. A war and indeed wads in the middle east will change and finalise this developed struggle .The differences in Izmir options in the west and Middle East are becoming manifest and with that a solidarity of a tolerant civility wl predominate. Mamdani does not understand the history and opponents of fascism in Europe and America and it’s influence on the middle east.The slow and to rtuos death of colonialism in its wake must not be confused with the nature of fascism it only has similarities. The fascism manifesting itself in Isis will leadtodeepdivisions in the middle east which will politicise Islamic Europe and America…..towards seeking a better deal as a minority not on opposition but on the reform of tolerance and civility in their interest… The emergent fanaticism in the middle east will be totally defeated in the middle east. The real dangers lie in the forf
far east. India and Pakistan…A. Daniel sees perpetrators in the west just a touch too close to a sense of conspiracy. Sectional fascism does not control the west.
Really nice design and style and excellent subject matter, nothing at all else we want : D.
Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an very long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say wonderful blog!
Dead pent content material, thankyou for information .
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on that. And he actually bought me lunch since I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!
I was looking at some of your content on this site and I conceive this internet site is real informative ! Continue putting up.
Can I simply say what a relief to search out someone who truly knows what theyre speaking about on the internet. You definitely know find out how to bring a problem to gentle and make it important. More people have to read this and perceive this aspect of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you undoubtedly have the gift.
Thanks for helping out, superb info. “Whoever obeys the gods, to him they particularly listen.” by Homer.
You got a very excellent website, Gladiola I observed it through yahoo.
Its like you learn my thoughts! You seem to grasp a lot about this, like you wrote the e-book in it or something. I feel that you simply can do with a few percent to drive the message house a bit, however instead of that, this is wonderful blog. A great read. I’ll definitely be back.
It’s truly a great and helpful piece of information. I’m happy that you shared this useful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
Can I just say what a aid to search out someone who actually is aware of what theyre speaking about on the internet. You positively know how you can convey an issue to gentle and make it important. More folks have to read this and understand this aspect of the story. I cant consider youre not more in style since you positively have the gift.
Thanks for helping out, great info .
This is a topic close to my heart cheers, where are your contact details though?
I have not checked in here for some time because I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂
Nice read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch as I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! “High living and high thinking are poles apart.” by B. J. Gupta.
I found your blog web site on google and verify a few of your early posts. Continue to maintain up the very good operate. I simply further up your RSS feed to my MSN Information Reader. Looking for forward to studying more from you later on!…
Awsome article and right to the point. I don’t know if this is actually the best place to ask but do you folks have any ideea where to employ some professional writers? Thx 🙂
I went over this site and I conceive you have a lot of good information, saved to favorites (:.
I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great posts.
Keep working ,fantastic job!
An interesting discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers
very nice post, i definitely love this web site, carry on it
I am extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a nice blog like this one today..
I was wondering if you ever considered changing the page layout of your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 images. Maybe you could space it out better?
Get-X – онлайн игра с реальным выводом средств. В неё входят азартные игры, где можно делать ставки, например, Краш.
certainly like your web-site however you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to inform the truth nevertheless I will certainly come again again.
Thanks for another fantastic post. Where else may just anybody get that type of information in such a perfect approach of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information.
I like this weblog very much so much good info .
I reckon something truly interesting about your web site so I saved to my bookmarks.
Only a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw great style and design.
WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. …
I want to point out my passion for your kindness supporting folks that should have help on this important niche. Your real commitment to passing the solution throughout appeared to be particularly advantageous and have frequently permitted professionals like me to reach their aims. The warm and friendly publication implies so much to me and additionally to my office colleagues. Best wishes; from everyone of us.
It is really a nice and helpful piece of info. I’m happy that you shared this useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.
Greetings! Very helpful advice on this article! It is the little changes that make the biggest changes. Thanks a lot for sharing!
Great paintings! That is the type of info that should be shared across the net. Disgrace on the search engines for now not positioning this publish upper! Come on over and visit my website . Thank you =)
Very instructive and excellent body structure of articles, now that’s user friendly (:.
Magnificent web site. A lot of useful information here. I’m sending it to several friends ans also sharing in delicious. And of course, thanks for your sweat!
I’m really inspired with your writing skills and also with the structure on your blog. Is this a paid subject or did you modify it your self? Either way keep up the nice high quality writing, it is rare to peer a great weblog like this one today..
Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Terrific blog and superb design.
Hey there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work due to no backup. Do you have any methods to protect against hackers?
Very nice pattern and fantastic articles, hardly anything else we need : D.
certainly like your web-site however you need to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth nevertheless I?¦ll surely come again again.
Very good written information. It will be supportive to everyone who utilizes it, including myself. Keep up the good work – can’r wait to read more posts.
I am always browsing online for ideas that can facilitate me. Thank you!
Some truly wondrous work on behalf of the owner of this site, absolutely great written content.
Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.
I’d constantly want to be update on new blog posts on this web site, saved to bookmarks! .
It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt donate to this brilliant blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!
Hi, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam responses? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can advise? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any support is very much appreciated.
Fantastic website. Plenty of useful information here. I am sending it to several buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious. And certainly, thanks on your effort!
Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem with your web site in web explorer, would check this?K IE nonetheless is the marketplace chief and a large element of people will leave out your great writing due to this problem.
Woah! I’m really loving the template/theme of this website. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appearance. I must say you have done a awesome job with this. In addition, the blog loads super quick for me on Safari. Exceptional Blog!
Hello there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my facebook group? There’s a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thank you
Some really interesting info , well written and broadly user genial.
I got what you mean , thanks for putting up.Woh I am glad to find this website through google.
I and also my pals were found to be looking through the nice helpful hints from your web blog and then I had a horrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the web blog owner for those secrets. The young men are already thrilled to learn all of them and already have unquestionably been taking advantage of them. Appreciate your being indeed considerate and for obtaining variety of beneficial things millions of individuals are really desperate to understand about. Our own sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to you earlier.
Would you be curious about exchanging hyperlinks?
Hi there very nice website!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds alsoKI’m glad to find numerous useful information right here in the post, we want work out more techniques on this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .
We are a bunch of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with useful information to paintings on. You have done an impressive process and our whole neighborhood can be grateful to you.
F*ckin’ amazing things here. I’m very glad to see your article. Thanks a lot and i’m looking forward to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?
What i do not realize is in truth how you’re no longer actually a lot more smartly-preferred than you might be right now. You’re so intelligent. You know therefore considerably in the case of this subject, made me for my part consider it from so many numerous angles. Its like men and women don’t seem to be involved except it?¦s one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga! Your personal stuffs great. At all times handle it up!
I genuinely enjoy reading on this website, it has superb posts. “Beware lest in your anxiety to avoid war you obtain a master.” by Demosthenes.
You actually make it seem really easy along with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually one thing that I believe I would never understand. It kind of feels too complicated and extremely extensive for me. I am having a look ahead to your subsequent submit, I?¦ll attempt to get the hold of it!
I like what you guys are up also. Such intelligent work and reporting! Carry on the superb works guys I have incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my website :).
This is a very good tips especially to those new to blogosphere, brief and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article.
Simply wanna input on few general things, The website pattern is perfect, the content material is rattling superb : D.
I’ve recently started a website, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work.